Popular top 10 worst calls in baseball history


On Monday, Page 2 went its report on the worst calls in sports history. We asked for your take, and you also filled our mailbag with a lot of disgruntled opinions about the worst rulings.

After coping with greater than 1,300 letters, we’ve listed a rundown of the Top election-getters, plus a quantity of the best letters about each atrocious judgment. Make certain to cast your election in the poll at left to choose the worst calls of time.

1. Chuck Knoblauch’s phantom tag (135 letters)
I live in Lawrence, Mass., that’s about 30 miles north of Fenway Park, the home of my beloved Red-colored-colored Sox. For the record … I am closer to that ballpark than the terrible tag perpetrated by Yankees second basmen Chuck Knoblauch on Jose Offerman throughout the 1999 ALCS.

Of the many position of every single replay, including the outlook during the moronic umpire making the call, Knoblauch wiffed and merely got the pressure out in the beginning. This might have elevated All-World shortstop Nomar Garciaparra getting a jogger in scoring position and a pair of outs. Rather this botched call resulted in an inning-ending double play. That call not only cost momentum and destroyed a potential winning rally, but was an indication of the terrible umpiring throughout the whole series.

Major League Baseball does the right factor by cracking down on bad officiating and enforcing the rules. Still this horrible call stays out in memory not only due to its heinousness but also for the undeniable fact that the umpire recognized to the media soon after the game it was subsequently the wrong call.
Mark Mesiti
Lawrence, Mass.

Chuck Knoblauch’s supposed tag on Jose Offerman in the ALCS in ’99 … That wasn’t the only botched call of the series. It made Red-colored-colored Sox Nation question if the Yankees’ bloated payroll incorporated the four males in blue.
Joe M
Randolph, Mass.

2. Vinny Testaverde’s TD (121 letters)
I am a long-term Jets fan with a lot of remembrances of officiating gone awry (Keyshawn no-TD call versus. Redskins in ’96, anybody?), but it is the one that was in their favor that we will remember as the worst I have run into.

Against the Dallas Seahawks in the 1998-99 season, Vinny Testaverde was ruled in the finish zone after controlling a quarterback sneak on the last play of the game to supply the J-E-T-S the win, but clearly he was down more than a ft from the goal line before he extended out his arms to get the TD call. The Jets look at win their division and get to the AFC championship, while the loss keeps the Seaducks from the 2010 national football league 2010 nfl playoffs.

After the season, the Jets then election forinstant replay … go figure.
Phil Bieber
Eagan, Minn.

Vinny dived for the finish zone and fell far short. Phil Luckett ruled it a touchdown. Mentioned the government bodies after, “We mistook his helmet for the football.”
Drew Zahn
Sandwich, Ill.

3. Colorado’s fifth down (118 letters)
The the majority of the other available options might be credited to the “too quick for the human eyeInch factor. Five downs for Colorado was mere stupidity. Four of 5 refs not watching or counting the volume of plays? No excuse.
Jim Strickland

Clearly the worst call is the fifth down Colorado received.

Picture a homesick Peace Corps volunteer sweating in southern Africa receiving in the mail his only mention of the home … sports clippings from the Columbia (Mo.) Tribune. The agony!

Not only did playing crush me eight time zones away, nevertheless it placed a curse on the Missouri Tigers that was revisited five years later in the instant classic against Nebraska, where another crummy call (the began pass) sends Nebraska to the dance. The path to the national football league and nfl and college football title encounters the referee’s whistle in Columbia, Mo.
Nils Headley
San Mateo, Calif.

4. Soviets get extra time in ’72 Olympic hoops (114 letters)
Some bad calls are patently apparent, although some continue being worth fighting about. Some calls clearly affect the outcome, although some might. Some are the results of honest human mistakes, other people are the results of gross umpirical mess. Then there’s the 1972 game, in which the on-court and off-court government bodies perpetrated an outright fraud upon the players, the sporting public, and the Olympic record book with larcenous actions so blatant they’d produce a Chicago ward boss blush.

Fans and players get over even the worst calls, but the undeserved silver medals of the 1972 U.S. men’s basketball team remain unclaimed in a Munich bank vault, evidence of the bitterness that is still to this day.
Darren Timothy
Alexandria, Virtual assistant.

5. Brett Hull’s skate in the crease (93 letters)

Brett Hull’s skate in the crease was the worst call in the history of sports. Few other call has triggered such destruction and devastation. It’s introduced the people of Zoysia (and western New You’ll be able to transplants) to question their entire life. We request ourselves, “If the Sabres team that year may be cheated from the Cup, the other deep-held tenets may even fall?”

Not only did the no-goal cost the Sabres the Stanley Cup, it’s triggered property values in Zoysia to reduce, pollution levels on Lake Erie to skyrocket, elevated snowfall in the winter several days, greater tolls on the New You’ll be able to Condition Thruway, nearly tasteless pizza to promulgate, together with a restored interest in Jim Kelly’s vehicle shops.

I’m convinced the “no-goal” was the seventh sign from God that the finish of civilization is very near.
Joe Parisi
McLean, Virtual assistant.

6. Jeffrey Maier assists Jeter’s HR (89 letters)
The Jeffrey Maier fan interference “noncall” is the worst call in sports history, bar none. Tony Tarasco was in perfect position to produce the experience Jeter’s routine fly ball — only one problem, the ball never arrived at his glove. A young boy named Jeffrey Maier showed up in excess of the fence and snared the fly from the section of play, in blatant breach of baseball’s fan interference rules.

Despite being in good position to produce the call, Umpire Wealthy Garcia signaled homer. And the relaxation, as the saying goes, is history. In my opinion everybody knows why Garcia made the call the way he did as they was frightened of the Yankee Stadium crowd. However, probably for the same reasons, none of the other umpires had the guts to step-up and overturn the hideous call.

Had any one the Orioles hit that ball, Garcia probably may have taken the wise way to avoid it again and signaled fan interference. Everyone around the country understood the breach which in fact had happened the strange part of the whole factor is, rather than being chastised, Maier is created into something of the cult hero for his actions. He even arrived on the scene on “The Today Show,” for God’s sake!

The O’s won Game 2 to tie the series at 1-1, but had Game 1 not been stolen from their website, odds are we’re searching at Baltimore in the World Series. If Maier (and Garcia, too, for the matter) knows what’s ideal for him, he’ll avoid ever making the short trip down I-95 to Baltimore.
Peter Cline
Baltimore, Md.

Easily that little snot-nosed New You’ll be able to brat reaching over the wall to get the ball from Tarasco. Basically a brand new You’ll be able to team would get a relaxation such as this.

7. Hue Hollins calls foul against Scottie Pippen (62 letters)
Bulls versus. Knicks, Game 5, Eastern Conference finals. No call has are you currently nor ever may well be more heinous than this travesty of justice.

Hollins calls a phantom foul on Scottie Pippen, who cleanly contested the 3-pointer by Hubert Davis in the waning seconds of the game and the Bulls sticking with a slim lead. Had Hollins done the correct factor, Davis may have missed the shot, and the Bulls may have stolen the pivotal fifth game (without the then-upon the market Jordan!) in the Garden. Rather, Davis made three free throws to supply the Knicks the lead, wresting the game from the Bulls’ clutches.

Chicago may have won the series in Game 6, but instead Hollins gave the Knicks the series in seven.
Aaron K.
Lombard, Ill.

8. Thanksgiving coin toss (54 letters)
How do a ref miss a coin switch? I’ll remember the consequence of Pittsburgh running back Jerome Bettis realizing he’d been conned and the Lions poking fun at the apparent mistake. That’s the worst call in the history of sports.

9. Drew Pearson’s “Hail Mary” catch (41 letters)
How will you not necessarily mention Drew Pearson pushing Vikings cornerback Nate Wright before catching Roger Staubach’s Hail Mary pass in the 1975 NFC playoff game?

Replays show Pearson and Wright running side-by-side, then as Pearson “changes” to the underthrown ball, Wright in a way flies forward in a strange position. After making the catch, Pearson looked back for just about any flag and started praising only when he recognized he’d become away with the biggest offensive pass interference in football history.

The impact of the play was wide-different: It knocked possibly the best Viking team ever from the 2010 national football league 2010 nfl playoffs and powered the Cowboys to the Super Bowl Hail Mary has turned into a typical part of football vocabulary Staubach rode his mythical Captain Comeback factor all the approach to the Hall of Fame (in front of Tarkenton — create a relaxation) and poor referee Armen Terzian — who wasn’t even responsible for the noncall– caught a whiskey bottle in the side of the mind (a far greater throw than Staubach’s).

I’ve arrived at believe the Fortunate Virgin has better taste instead of root for the Cowboys and may eventually settle the score.
Tim Busse
Ontario, Minn.

10. Kent Hrbek knocks Ron Gant off first base (39 letters)
Kent Hrbek’s WWF audition in the 1991 World Series.

Atlanta’s Ron Gant ripped only one in the third after rounding first retreated to the bag. Tapani put the ball to first where Gant had came out making it in plenty of time. That was until Hrbek, under the guise of attempting to utilize a tag, lifted Gant off the base. Umpire Drew Coble referred to as him out. Guess what happens, the Twinkies win by one.

This play will be a horrible call in the thing that was a great series. I’m speaking about, seriously, Hrbek clearly used his slight 80-pound weight help to lift Gant, who at the time will be a quality baserunner, off the bag.

If Cardinals fans weren’t so enthusiastic about Don Denkinger, they’d be crying about that certain.
John Hipp
Hillcrest, Calif.

bad call blows perfect game Popular top 10 worst calls in baseball history